Looking for a Lightroom Replacement?

Issue #256 — Here’s What I’d Tell You

Composite of Stock Images Created by Anthony Morganti, a Long Time Ago

Please Note:

1. I’m an affiliate for several companies mentioned here: Adobe, DxO, On1, Luminar, Radiant Photo, and ACDSee. The links listed below ARE NOT my affiliate links. I don’t want anybody to get the impression that I’m only writing this to earn affiliate commissions; hence, if you click on any link and buy anything, I won’t make any money.

2. Pricing may vary depending on your country or when you’re looking at the current prices for any product I mention.

3. Of course, there are several other applications available beyond what I’ve listed in this article. The apps listed are apps that I’m most familiar with and have used.

---

Lately, I’ve noticed that more and more photographers are looking for a “Lightroom replacement.” I understand why. Some want out of Adobe’s subscription model. Some want better RAW quality. Some want stronger noise reduction. Some just want a program that feels more direct and less bloated.

The first thing I’d say is this: there is no perfect one-to-one Lightroom replacement.

There are only trade-offs.

That is why this question is harder than it sounds. Lightroom is not just a RAW editor. It is also a catalog, an organizer, a batch processor, a syncing system, and, for many photographers, the center of their entire workflow. Adobe still sells a Lightroom plan for $11.99 per month, and its Photography plan with Lightroom, Lightroom Classic, Photoshop, and 1TB of storage is $19.99 per month. So before you leave it, you need to be clear about what you are replacing and why.

If what you want is the closest thing to a high-end professional replacement, I’d start with Capture One. This is the one I’d point serious studio shooters, commercial photographers, and anyone who cares deeply about color first. Capture One leans hard into color precision, tethering, and a pro workflow. The upside is obvious. It is built for demanding photographers. The downside is just as obvious. It is expensive. Capture One’s site currently lists prices between $26 and $59 per month, depending on which plan you purchase – Pro, All-in-One, or Studio – with a substantial discount if you pay for a year. Also available is a perpetual Pro license at $329. For many people, that price alone will quickly narrow the field.

If what you care about most is image quality at the RAW level, especially noise reduction and optical corrections, DxO PhotoLab deserves a serious look. DxO is leaning into DeepPRIME noise reduction, AI masks, lens corrections, and what it calls laboratory-grade corrections. In plain English, it is aimed at photographers who want clean files and excellent technical quality. The current version is PhotoLab 9. The catch is price and workflow fit. DxO PhotoLab 9 is currently listed at $239.99 (Updgrade $119.99). I also don’t think of DxO first as a catalog-driven hub in the Lightroom sense. I think of it first as a RAW developer that produces beautiful files.

If you want an all-in-one program that is clearly trying to be both a Lightroom and Photoshop replacement, ON1 Photo RAW is one of the most obvious choices. ON1 pitches itself as one app for RAW processing, editing, layers, effects, and photo management. That is attractive. Many photographers do not want to juggle multiple programs. ON1 also leans heavily into AI tools like masking, noise reduction, resizing, sky replacement, and generative erase. The downside is that all-in-one software can sometimes feel like too much. ON1’s current special-pricing page shows Photo RAW 2026.3 at $49.99 and Photo RAW MAX 2026.3 at $79.99, which makes it look like a strong value right now.

If your priority is ease of use and AI-assisted editing, Luminar Neo is still one of the more appealing options. Skylum has built Neo around speed, easy-to-use tools, layers, AI features, and flexible licensing. It can run as a standalone app or as a plug-in for Photoshop and Lightroom Classic. That is the good news. The part that may give some photographers pause is that the pricing model can get a little confusing, and Skylum says big upgrades may require extra payments even with a perpetual license. At the moment, the desktop perpetual license is $119, the cross-device perpetual license is $159, and the max license is $179. If you like AI help and want a friendly interface, it makes sense. If you want a more traditional, disciplined workflow tool, it may not be your first choice.

If you’re a Windows user, one product that I think gets overlooked too often is ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate 2026. ACDSee aims to bring digital asset management, RAW editing, layered editing, and a growing list of AI tools together in one place. The current version adds AI Denoise, AI Hair Masking, and AI Develop Presets, and ACDSee makes a big point of the fact that you do not have to import your photos the way you do in Lightroom. Some photographers will love that. Others may miss the structure Lightroom imposes. The price is also very reasonable compared to some competitors. A subscription is listed at $89 per year, and the perpetual license is $89.95 as of today. That puts it squarely in the conversation for photographers who want a lot of functionality without paying Capture One money. One note, though; historically, the Mac version would be missing features that were in the Windows version. I’m not sure if that is still the case.

Now let’s talk about Radiant Photo 2, because it often comes up in this conversation, even though I don’t really think it belongs in the same category. Radiant is built around assistive AI, scene detection, local processing, and fast enhancement. It is trying to get a photo looking good very quickly. That is its strength. The company’s own language makes that clear. It is about speed, simplicity, and genre-specific workflows. The problem is that I do not see it as a true Lightroom replacement for most photographers. I see it more as a companion tool or finishing tool. Radiant’s site currently shows $159 for the base version, with optional workflow add-ons at $79 each. They currently have workflows for Landscape, Portraiture, Pets, and Birds. So yes, it looks useful. But if you are trying to replace Lightroom as the center of your whole workflow, Radiant would not be my first recommendation.

If your main goal is simply to get away from subscriptions and spend nothing, then the two names you need to know are darktable and RawTherapee. darktable describes itself as an open-source photography workflow application and RAW developer. It manages files in a database and gives you a lighttable and darkroom approach that will feel familiar to some Lightroom users. RawTherapee is also free and open source, and it remains a very capable RAW processor. The current RawTherapee download page lists version 5.12, released May 28, 2025, and its documentation states that it edits non-destructively via sidecar files. The drawback with both programs is not the price. It is polish, ease of use, and learning curve. Free software can be very powerful. It can also ask more of you.

There is also Exposure X7, which is still worth mentioning because some photographers prefer software that feels more photographic and less corporate. Exposure offers precise adjustments, creative looks, noise reduction, standalone use, and plug-in support for Lightroom and Photoshop. The company is still selling it for $129 without a subscription. My hesitation is simple: the product line is still on X7, and Exposure’s own announcement for X7 dates back to 2021. That does not make it bad. It just makes it harder for me to put it in the top tier of current Lightroom alternatives in 2026.

So what is the best Lightroom replacement?

For studio work and color-critical editing, I’d look hardest at Capture One.

For RAW quality, noise reduction, and lens corrections, I’d look hard at DxO PhotoLab.

For an all-in-one buy-it-once alternative, ON1 Photo RAW makes a lot of sense.

For ease of use, Luminar Neo is attractive.

For value and feature depth, ACDSee is more interesting than many people realize, but keep in mind that the Mac version may be lacking.

For fast finishing, Radiant Photo 2 looks useful, but I would not treat it as a full Lightroom replacement.

For free, darktable and RawTherapee are the real conversation.

At the end of the day, most photographers are not really looking for a Lightroom replacement.

They are looking for a better fit.

And that is a different question.

Current prices and links I found today

• Adobe Lightroom
  Lightroom plan: $11.99/month
  Photography plan with Photoshop: $19.99/month

• Capture One Pro
  $26 - $59/month (Depending on plan, with heavy discounts for yearly purchase)
  $329 one-time Perpetual Pro license

• DxO PhotoLab
  $239.99

• ON1 Photo RAW
  The current ON1 special-pricing page shows Photo RAW 2026 at $49.99
  Photo RAW MAX 2026 at $79.99

• Luminar Neo
  Desktop perpetual: $119
  Cross-device perpetual: $159
  Max license: $179

• ACDSee Photo Studio Ultimate 2026
  $89/year subscription
  $89.95 perpetual license

• Radiant Photo 2
  $159 standalone or plugin
  $79 per Workflow Add-on

• darktable
  Free

• RawTherapee
  Free

• Exposure X7
  $129

---

Some of the Places You Can Find Me:

• My Website: https://www.anthonymorganti.com/

• My YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@anthonymorganti

• Medium: https://medium.com/@anthonymorganti